A mental health nurse is caring for a client who smokes and has lung cancer.
The client reports, "I'm coughing because I have that cold everyone has been getting." The nurse should identify that the client is using which of the following defense mechanisms?

Choice A rationale:

Intrusive and judgmental: Asking "Why did you wear clean clothes and comb your hair today?" directly challenges the client's behavior and implies that she needs to justify her actions. This can make the client feel defensive and less likely to open up.

Focuses on the past: The directs attention to the client's previous lack of self-care, which can reinforce negative feelings and discourage progress.

Assumes motivation: It presumes that the client made a conscious decision to change her appearance based on a specific reason, which may not be accurate and can invalidate her experience.

Choice B rationale:

Presumptuous and premature: Concluding that "Your mood must be lifting because you have on clean clothes and have combed your hair" makes assumptions about the client's internal state without proper assessment.

Oversimplifies depression: It suggests that improvements in self-care directly equate to mood improvement, which disregards the complexity of depression and its varied manifestations.

Can create pressure: The statement can inadvertently pressure the client to feel or act a certain way to meet the nurse's expectations, hindering genuine progress.

Choice D rationale:

Paternalistic and condescending: Expressing "Oh, I'm so pleased that you finally put on clean clothes" implies that the nurse has been waiting for or expecting this change, placing the nurse in a position of authority and potentially undermining the client's autonomy.

Focuses on the nurse's feelings: The statement centers on the nurse's approval rather than acknowledging the client's efforts and perspective.

Can reinforce dependency: It can foster a dynamic where the client seeks external validation for her actions, rather than developing internal motivation for self-care.

Choice C rationale:

Observational and non-judgmental: The statement "I see that you have on clean clothes and have combed your hair" simply acknowledges the client's actions without imposing any interpretation or judgment.

Invites conversation: It provides an opportunity for the client to elaborate on her choices if she feels comfortable, promoting autonomy and self-expression.

Validates effort: It subtly recognizes the client's efforts without explicitly praising or criticizing, fostering a sense of self- efficacy and encouraging continued self-care.

Demonstrates active listening: It shows that the nurse has been paying attention to the client's progress, which can strengthen the therapeutic relationship and build trust.

Choice A rationale:

This statement is accusatory and blaming, rather than promoting understanding and problem-solving. It focuses on the negative behavior of the sibling and seeks external validation for the speaker's feelings, rather than attempting to address the underlying issue directly with the sibling.

It uses "should" language, which can come across as judgmental and critical, potentially escalating conflict.

It does not express the speaker's own feelings or needs, making it difficult for the other person to understand and respond effectively.

Choice B rationale:

While this statement demonstrates a willingness to take responsibility for actions, it does not directly address the communication between the family members. It focuses on redirecting the father's anger rather than exploring the underlying reasons for the conflict.

It could be interpreted as silencing the children's voices and potentially reinforcing a hierarchical dynamic within the family, where one parent holds authority over the others.

Choice C rationale:

This statement is manipulative and threatening, using a fear of exposure to control the other person's behavior. It undermines trust and safety within the family, making it difficult to have open and honest communication.

It does not address the core issue at hand and instead escalates conflict by using a "tit-for-tat" approach.

Choice D rationale:

This statement effectively demonstrates several key principles of effective communication: It expresses curiosity and a genuine desire to understand the other person's perspective.

It avoids accusations or assumptions, instead inviting open dialogue.

It focuses on specific behaviors and events ("each time you go to the mall") rather than making sweeping generalizations about the person's character.

It uses "I" language to express the speaker's own feelings and concerns, inviting empathy and understanding.

It creates an opportunity for the other person to share their perspective and work towards a resolution together.