A nurse is planning discharge for a client who has borderline personality disorder. Which of the following interventions should be included for this client?

Choice A rationale:

Judgmental and challenging: Asking "Why did you feel you needed to do that at this time?" implies that the parents' decision may not have been the best one. It puts them on the defensive and could make them feel like they need to justify their actions.

Not empathetic: This response does not acknowledge the parents' feelings of sadness, disappointment, or loss. It focuses on the decision itself rather than on the emotional impact it has had on the family.

Not supportive: The nurse's role is to provide support and understanding, not to the parents' decisions. This response does not offer any emotional support or validation.

Choice B rationale:

Empathetic and validating: This response acknowledges the parents' feelings and shows that the nurse understands how difficult it must have been to cancel their son's baseball registration. It also validates their decision, which can be helpful in coping with difficult situations.

Opens up communication: By expressing empathy, the nurse encourages the parents to share their feelings and experiences. This can help them to process their emotions and feel more supported.

Facilitates understanding: By recognizing the parents' frustration, the nurse can better understand their perspective and provide more tailored support. This can help to strengthen the nurse-client relationship and promote trust.

Choice C rationale:

False hope: While it is possible that the child's condition could improve, it is not realistic to offer false hope to the parents. This response could make it more difficult for them to accept the reality of their child's illness and could lead to disappointment and frustration in the future.

Dismissive of feelings: This response does not acknowledge the parents' current feelings of sadness and loss. It focuses on the future, which can be overwhelming and anxiety-provoking for parents who are facing a terminal illness.

Choice D rationale:

Irrelevant and insensitive: The dangers of baseball are not relevant to the parents' decision to cancel their son's registration. This response is dismissive of their feelings and does not offer any support or understanding.

Potentially offensive: This response could be interpreted as suggesting that the parents are being overprotective or that they are making a decision based on fear rather than on their child's best interests.

Rationale:

Choice A: Avoid discussing past behaviors with the client is incorrect. While avoiding dwelling on the past is important, discussing past manipulative behaviors in a safe and therapeutic environment can help the client gain insight into their patterns and triggers. This awareness is crucial for developing future coping mechanisms and preventing further manipulation.

Choice C: Allow manipulation so as to not raise the client's anxiety is incorrect. Allowing manipulation reinforces the behavior and undermines the client's well-being. It also sets a dangerous precedent for interactions with others.

While addressing anxiety is important, it should not be at the cost of condoning manipulation.

Choice D: Bargain with the client to discourage manipulative behavior is incorrect. Bargaining implies making concessions in exchange for the client stopping their manipulation. This approach can be ineffective and even reinforce the manipulative behavior as the client learns to negotiate for desired outcomes. Instead, clear boundaries and consistent consequences are more effective in addressing manipulation.

Rationale for Choice B:

Instituting consequences for manipulative behavior provides a clear and consistent response to the client's actions. This can help to limit the behavior and encourage the client to develop alternative coping mechanisms.

Consequences should be:

Fair and proportional: The consequence should be related to the specific manipulative behavior and not be overly harsh or punitive.

Consistent: The same consequence should be applied each time the manipulative behavior occurs. This predictability helps the client understand the cause-and-effect relationship between their actions and the consequences.

Enforceable: The consequence should be something that can be realistically implemented and followed through on. While implementing consequences, it's important to:

Maintain a therapeutic relationship: Address the behavior in a calm and professional manner, focusing on the behavior itself and not personal attacks.

Communicate clearly: Explain the consequences to the client in advance and ensure they understand the connection between their actions and the outcome.

Provide alternative coping mechanisms: Offer the client support and guidance in developing healthier ways to express their needs and manage their emotions.

By setting clear boundaries and consistently implementing consequences, nurses can help clients with manipulative behaviors learn to interact in a more positive and productive way. This ultimately benefits the client, their relationships, and their overall well-being.