A nurse is planning care for a group of clients on a mental health unit. Which of the following actions should the nurse plan to take to create a therapeutic environment?

Choice A Reason: While this response may seem compassionate, it does not encourage the client to engage in activities that could benefit their mental health. Allowing the client to remain isolated may reinforce feelings of helplessness or depression. It is important to motivate clients to participate in therapeutic activities to promote their recovery.

Choice B Reason: This response is supportive and offers a compromise. It acknowledges the client’s current state and provides assistance, while also gently encouraging participation in activities. By offering help and allowing for rest afterward, the nurse is using an empathetic approach to facilitate the client’s involvement in the unit’s programs.

Choice C Reason: This response is coercive and could be considered a threat. It is not therapeutic to withhold basic needs such as meals as a form of punishment or to force compliance. Such an approach can damage the nurse-client relationship and is not conducive to the client’s recovery.

Choice D Reason: This response may come across as dismissive and demanding. It does not offer support or acknowledge the client’s feelings. Telling the client what they “need” to do without offering help or understanding can lead to resistance and a lack of trust in the nurse-client relationship.

Choice A Reason:
This statement is an example of assertive communication because it acknowledges the client's feelings while also standing firm on the nurse's actions. Assertive communication is characterized by being direct, clear, concise, honest, confident, and respectful¹. It involves expressing thoughts and feelings in a considerate way that respects others, aiming to foster and maintain healthy relationships, rectify conflicts, and prevent resentment due to unexpressed needs.

Choice B Reason:
Telling a client to calm down can be perceived as dismissive and may not be considered assertive communication. It does not acknowledge the client's feelings and can come across as commanding or condescending, which may escalate the situation rather than resolve it.

Choice C Reason:
While this statement does convey the consequences of the client's actions, it lacks the empathy component that is crucial in assertive communication. It is important to balance directness with understanding when addressing sensitive issues.

Choice D Reason:
Asking why the client chose to behave negatively could be seen as confrontational and may put the client on the defensive. Assertive communication aims to avoid power games and foster clear outcomes, which is best achieved through statements that do not provoke or blame.