Group therapy is strongly encouraged, but not mandatory, in an inpatient psychiatric unit. The unit manager’s policy is that clients can make a choice about whether or not to attend group therapy. Which ethical principle does the unit manager’s policy preserve?

Choice A Reason:

While this response attempts to offer support, it makes an assumption about the mother’s understanding without addressing the client’s feelings directly. Therapeutic communication should focus on validating the client’s emotions and encouraging them to express their thoughts and feelings. This response might not fully acknowledge the client’s distress.

Choice B Reason:

This response normalizes the client’s feelings, which can be helpful, but it does not directly address the client’s specific concern. While it is important to reassure the client that their feelings are common, the response should also validate their individual experience and encourage further discussion.

Choice C Reason:

Encouraging the client to talk to their mother is a proactive suggestion, but it may not be the most therapeutic initial response. The client might not be ready to take that step, and the nurse should first focus on understanding and validating the client’s feelings before suggesting actions. This response could be more appropriate as a follow-up after the client’s feelings have been explored.

Choice D Reason:

This response is the most therapeutic because it uses reflective listening to validate the client’s feelings. By restating what the client has expressed, the nurse shows empathy and encourages the client to explore their emotions further. This technique helps the client feel heard and understood, which is crucial in therapeutic communication.

Choice A Reason:

“This is a difficult transition. Let’s formulate a plan to keep you feeling safe.”

This response is the most supportive because it acknowledges the client’s feelings and offers a proactive solution. By recognizing the difficulty of the transition and suggesting a plan to ensure the client’s safety, the nurse provides reassurance and practical support. This approach helps to build trust and shows empathy, which is crucial in a therapeutic relationship.

Choice B Reason:

“It’s the policy that patients can only live here for 30 days. Let’s try to extend it.”

While this response acknowledges the client’s fear, it focuses on policy rather than addressing the client’s immediate emotional needs. Extending the stay might not be feasible or beneficial in the long term. The primary goal should be to empower the client to feel safe and supported outside the facility.

Choice C Reason:

“You’ve had a month to come up with a plan to work on your well-being.”

This response can come across as dismissive and unsupportive. It implies that the client should have already resolved their fears, which may increase their anxiety and feelings of inadequacy. The focus should be on providing immediate support and reassurance rather than criticizing the client’s progress.

Choice D Reason:

“Hopefully you learned from being in counseling. I’m sure this will work out fine.”

This response is overly optimistic and does not address the client’s current fears. It provides false reassurance without offering any concrete support or solutions. The client needs to feel heard and supported, not just reassured that everything will be fine.